Mind Moving

By: Vijay Balakrishnan
January 23, 2012

Case 29 of the Mumonkan:

Two monks were watching a flag waving in the wind. One said, “The flag is moving.”
The other said, “The wind is moving.”
Huineng, overhearing, said, “Not the wind. Not the flag. Your mind is moving.” The monks were startled.

Huineng’s statement isn’t conclusive either, but only another provocation. The wind surely moves, the flag surely moves. Is he merely trying to shake up his pedantic students to stop them from useless speculation?

Mind is moving, says Huineng, and the inquiry is pushed one layer back, the movement of flag or wind logically only present to a mind, the event calibrated to the specifics of our perceptual limits and subjectivity. We do not even know how the movement might register to a fruit-bat or a cockroach, much less to a being in another dimension.

[3rd avenue]

If the mind is moving, what then is still? The first question of meditation is also, infuriatingly, the last.

As an artist of the reflected world, I looked into puddles for possibilities, and found many wonders there, the tops of buildings, clouds, trees, birds, all shining up out of the collected detritus of city life. I saw wind and water and mind on the move, and for moments dissolve into stillness.

[91st street]

…the universe is reflected in the mind like the sun on the water.

—Vijnanabhairava Tantra


Read more from artist-in-residence Vijay Balakrishnan on HiLobrow.


HILOBROW’s Artist-in-residence archive.


Art, Kudos, Read-outs