CROSS YOUR ENTHUSIASM (14)
By:
November 17, 2026
One in a series of enthusiastic posts, contributed by 25 HILOBROW friends and regulars, analyzing and celebrating our favorite… creators switching art forms and/or careers! Series edited by Adam McGovern.
SYDNEY POLLACK, CHARACTER ACTOR

What’s surprising about the late career of Sydney Pollack is not that the Oscar-winning director made his way in front of the camera, but that he did so repeatedly, in character roles, with nearly each in a distinct genre of men prone to go for the kill. Specializing in sinister lawyers (and in Eyes Wide Shut, a lawyer-adjacent), Pollack hung out his shingle playing villains who serve to remind younger male characters that, high-minded ideals to the contrary, they’d managed to worm themselves into a world of compromise. A la the clever theory advanced in Bennett Sims’s excellent short story “White Dialogues,” that James Stewart is playing a single character across Vertigo and Rear Window, a too-cute viewer might be tempted to read Pollack’s shadowy, elite men as different iterations of the same character. The clues are there for the kind of viewer who hangs out in YouTube comment sections: Pollack’s men conspire, and Pollack’s men pollute — the best two films in which he acts are Eyes Wide Shut and Michael Clayton; his character in the latter is less conspiratorial than in the former, though by many leagues more environmentally destructive. (In the lesser efforts Changing Lanes and A Civil Action, two of Pollack’s lawyers are deeply into sailing.)
But the shared-universe reading of Pollack’s men is too easy a handle by which to pick up his filmography. Like many men who’ve won Oscars for directing — the Eastwoods and the Beattys — Pollack’s entry into showbusiness was as a performer, but unlike his superstar-turned-director analogues, Pollack’s pre-directing acting resume is limited. First graduating to being an acting coach, Pollack started directing at the behest of his friend Burt Lancaster (“He was chiseled out of marble… like when you look in a field and see a bunch of horses, and one has perfect conformation,” said Pollack in a retrospective documentary, a coincidental foreshadow to Michael Clayton’s essential opening set-piece); he didn’t act in a significant role until his own film Tootsie, thirteen features and nearly twenty years into his directorial career. (In Tootsie, too, Pollack plays that other conspiratorial polluter, an agent, even if this time played for laughs.) “[O]ne thing [that] remains absolutely constant in all of [Pollack’s films],” writes Laurent Tirard, “[is] the quality of acting,” and in an interview with Tirard, Pollack states “the harder it is to determine [which character] is right, the better the film is” — a preoccupation evident in the films he embraced as an actor.
It must be said that Pollack’s directorial efforts generally underwhelm. For every fascinating — if not auteurish — effort (Tootsie; They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?) there’s a fair amount of dreck, which rarely rises above a mid-level watermark of Hollywood house style. Pollack aptly called The Way We Were “hardly even a movie… just two performances that are touching”; and Out of Africa is — even by the standards of lesser Best Picture winners — unusually repellant to a contemporary viewer, a bloated, “well-meaning” affair that does little to counteract the “Africa is a country” myth that, in Pollack’s last film The Interpreter, he continues to advance — all while implausibly casting Nicole Kidman as an expat African dissident. (I can’t use a more specific adjective than “African” here, as the film chooses an invented African nation as its unspecific subject.)
Pollack’s directorial efforts in the legal thriller genre are not well served by retrospective, post-Michael Clayton viewings — a finding true not just of a workmanlike dud like The Firm but even the more palatable Absence of Malice. But, said Pollack, “Acting is a way of spying on other directors,” and it’s rewarding to imagine a reverse-flowing influence up from his flawed, well-acted cautionary characters and toward the best filmmakers — the Kubricks and the Gilroys, preoccupied with Pollackian themes of good lives in shadowed worlds — who directed him.
CROSS YOUR ENTHUSIASM: INTRODUCTION by Adam McGovern | James Scott Maloy on DAVID LEE ROTH, EMT | Lynn Peril on HEDY LAMARR AND GEORGE ANTHEIL, INVENTORS | Crockett Doob on LARS ULRICH, TENNIS ACE | Mimi Lipson on DANIEL DAY-LEWIS, COBBLER | Mariane Cara on BRIAN MAY, ASTROPHYSICIST | Carlo Rotella on CURTIS COKES, FIGHTING ACTOR | Josh Glenn on GEORGE HARRISON, FILM PRODUCER | Crystal Durant on SKUNK BAXTER, DEFENSE CONSULTANT | Adrienne Crew on HENRY ROLLINS, PUNK POLYMATH | Deborah Wassertzug on JOHN LURIE, DISRUPTOR | Heather Quinlan on HARRY NILSSON, COMPUTER GENIUS | Adam McGovern on JOSEPHINE BAKER, SPY | Douglas Wolk on RICHARD McGUIRE, GRAPHIC-LIT INNOVATOR | Jake Zucker on SYDNEY POLLACK, CHARACTER ACTOR | Rani Som on RACHEL POLLACK, SEEKER | Jeff Lewonczyk on ANDY WARHOL, FORMER ANDY WARHOL | Nikhil Singh on ADOLF HITLER, FORMER PAINTER | Holly Interlandi on ADAM JONES, DIRECTOR | Jonathan Pinchera on PETER CAINE, CONSPIRACY STAR | Miranda Mellis on EVE KOSOVSKY SEDGWICK, ACADEMIC WEAVER | Kelly Jean Fitzsimmons on BRENT SPINER, SINGING NOVELIST | Christopher-Rashee Stevenson on QUENTIN TARANTINO, CRITIC | Sangamithra Iyer on MADHUR ANAND, LITERARY ECOLOGIST | Marlon Stern Lopez on GREG GRAFFIN, HARDCORE ZOOLOGIST | Pichchenda Bao on WENDELL BERRY, FARMING POET.
JACK KIRBY PANELS | CAPTAIN KIRK SCENES | OLD-SCHOOL HIP HOP | TYPEFACES | NEW WAVE | SQUADS | PUNK | NEO-NOIR MOVIES | COMICS | SCI-FI MOVIES | SIDEKICKS | CARTOONS | TV DEATHS | COUNTRY | PROTO-PUNK | METAL | & more enthusiasms!